Skip to main content
Page: Last modified: 2023-10-12
Code Reference(s):
NBC20 Div.B 5.9.1.1. (first printing)
Subject:
Environmental Separation Table 5.9.1.1.
Title:
Deletion of Reference to Duplicate Standard
Description:
This proposed change deletes the reference to ASTM D2178/D2178M-13a, “Standard Specification for Asphalt Glass Felt Used in Roofing and Waterproofing,” from Table 5.9.1.1.
Problem
Part 5 of the NBC currently references both ASTM D2178/D2178M-13a, “Standard Specification for Asphalt Glass Felt Used in Roofing and Waterproofing,” and CSA-A123.17-05, “Asphalt Glass Felt Used in Roofing and Waterproofing”; however, ASTM D2178/D2178M was adopted, with Canadian deviations, as CSA-A123.17.
If ASTM D2178/D2178M were to remain in the NBC, it would cause confusion and conflict between designers, manufacturers, authorities having jurisdiction and the legal community. These conflicts would occur when
- authorities having jurisdiction request documentation from manufacturers during permit reviews to prove Code compliance,
- designers require Code compliance for use of their design specifications on a project, or
- lawyers demand proof of Code compliance during possible court cases.
Justification
At the mid-cycle review of updates to the standards currently referenced in Table 5.9.1.1., the Standing Committee on Environmental Separation determined that ASTM D2178/D2178M-13a and CSA-A123.17-05 are currently referenced in Part 5 despite the fact that ASTM D2178/D2178M has been adopted, with Canadian deviations, as CSA-A123.17. Therefore, the Standing Committee agreed to delete the reference to ASTM D2178/D2178M.
Deleting reference to ASTM D2178/D2178M from the NBC eliminates potential conflict and confusion for designers, manufacturers, authorities having jurisdiction and the legal community, as noted above.
PROPOSED CHANGE
NBC20 Div.B 5.9.1.1. (first printing)
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1.Compliance with Applicable Standards
[1] 1)Except as provided in Sentence (2) and elsewhere in this Part, materials and components, and their installation, shall conform to the requirements of the applicable standards in Table 5.9.1.1. where those materials or components are
[a] a)incorporated into environmental separators or assemblies exposed to the exterior, and
[b] b)installed to fulfill the requirements of this Part.
(See Note A-5.9.1.1.(1)PROPOSED CHANGE A-5.9.1.1.(1).)
[2] 2)The requirements for flame-spread ratings contained in thermal insulation standards shall be applied only as required in Part 3.
| Issuing Agency | Document Number | Title of Document |
|---|---|---|
| ANSI | A135.6 | Engineered Wood Siding |
| ASME | B18.6.1 | Wood Screws (Inch Series) |
| ASTM | A123/A123M | Standard Specification for Zinc (Hot-Dip Galvanized) Coatings on Iron and Steel Products |
| ASTM | A153/A153M | Standard Specification for Zinc Coating (Hot-Dip) on Iron and Steel Hardware |
| ASTM | A653/A653M | Standard Specification for Steel Sheet, Zinc-Coated (Galvanized) or Zinc-Iron Alloy-Coated (Galvannealed) by the Hot-Dip Process |
| ASTM | C4 | Standard Specification for Clay Drain Tile and Perforated Clay Drain Tile |
| ASTM | C73 | Standard Specification for Calcium Silicate Brick (Sand-Lime Brick) |
| ASTM | C126 | Ceramic Glazed Structural Clay Facing Tile, Facing Brick, and Solid Masonry Units |
| ASTM | C212 | Standard Specification for Structural Clay Facing Tile |
| ASTM | C412M | Standard Specification for Concrete Drain Tile |
| ASTM | C444M | Standard Specification for Perforated Concrete Pipe |
| ASTM | C553 | Standard Specification for Mineral Fiber Blanket Thermal Insulation for Commercial and Industrial Applications |
| ASTM | C612 | Standard Specification for Mineral Fiber Block and Board Thermal Insulation |
| ASTM | C700 | Standard Specification for Vitrified Clay Pipe, Extra Strength, Standard Strength, and Perforated |
| ASTM | C726 | Standard Specification for Mineral Wool Roof Insulation Board |
| ASTM | C834PROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (1) | Standard Specification for Latex Sealants |
| ASTM | C840 | Standard Specification for Application and Finishing of Gypsum Board |
| ASTM | C920PROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (1) | Standard Specification for Elastomeric Joint Sealants |
| ASTM | C991 | Standard Specification for Flexible Fibrous Glass Insulation for Metal Buildings |
| ASTM | C1002 | Standard Specification for Steel Self-Piercing Tapping Screws for the Application of Gypsum Panel Products or Metal Plaster Bases to Wood Studs or Steel Studs |
| ASTM | C1177/C1177M | Standard Specification for Glass Mat Gypsum Substrate for Use as Sheathing |
| ASTM | C1178/C1178M | Standard Specification for Coated Glass Mat Water-Resistant Gypsum Backing Panel |
| ASTM | C1184PROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (1) | Standard Specification for Structural Silicone Sealants |
| ASTM | C1280 | Standard Specification for Application of Exterior Gypsum Panel Products for Use as Sheathing |
| ASTM | C1311PROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (1) | Standard Specification for Solvent Release Sealants |
| ASTM | C1330PROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (1) | Standard Specification for Cylindrical Sealant Backing for Use with Cold Liquid-Applied Sealants |
| ASTM | C1396/C1396MPROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (2) | Standard Specification for Gypsum Board |
| ASTM | C1658/C1658MPROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (3) | Standard Specification for Glass Mat Gypsum Panels |
| ASTM | D1227/D1227M | Standard Specification for Emulsified Asphalt Used as a Protective Coating for Roofing |
| ASTM | D3019/D3019MPROPOSED CHANGE Table 5.9.1.1. Footnote (4) | Standard Specification for Lap Cement Used with Asphalt Roll Roofing, Non-Fibered, and Fibered |
| ASTM | D4479/D4479M | Standard Specification for Asphalt Roof Coatings – Asbestos-Free |
| ASTM | D4637/D4637M | Standard Specification for EPDM Sheet Used In Single-Ply Roof Membrane |
| ASTM | D4811/D4811M | Standard Specification for Nonvulcanized (Uncured) Rubber Sheet Used as Roof Flashing |
| ASTM | D6878/D6878M | Standard Specification for Thermoplastic Polyolefin Based Sheet Roofing |
| ASTM | E2190 | Standard Specification for Insulating Glass Unit Performance and Evaluation |
| BNQ | BNQ 3624-115 | Polyethylene (PE) Pipe and Fittings for Soil and Foundation Drainage |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-11.3-M | Hardboard |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-12.1 | Safety Glazing |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-12.2-M | Flat, Clear Sheet Glass |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-12.3-M | Flat, Clear Float Glass |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-12.4-M | Heat Absorbing Glass |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-12.8 | Insulating glass units |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-12.9 | Spandrel glass |
| CGSB | 37-GP-9Ma | Primer, Asphalt, Unfilled, for Asphalt Roofing, Dampproofing and Waterproofing |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-37.50-M | Hot-Applied, Rubberized Asphalt for Roofing and Waterproofing |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-37.54 | Polyvinyl Chloride Roofing and Waterproofing Membrane |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-37.58-M | Membrane, Elastomeric, Cold-Applied Liquid, for Non-Exposed Use in Roofing and Waterproofing |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-41.24 | Rigid Vinyl Siding, Soffits and Fascia |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-51.32-M | Sheathing, Membrane, Breather Type |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-51.33-M | Vapour Barrier Sheet, Excluding Polyethylene, for Use in Building Construction |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-51.34-M | Vapour Barrier, Polyethylene Sheet for Use in Building Construction |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-93.1-M | Sheet, Aluminum Alloy, Prefinished, Residential |
| CGSB | CAN/CGSB-93.2-M | Prefinished Aluminum Siding, Soffits, and Fascia, for Residential Use |
| CSA | A23.1 | Concrete materials and methods of concrete construction |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A82 | Fired masonry brick made from clay or shale |
| CSA | CAN3-A93-M | Natural Airflow Ventilators for Buildings |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A123.2 | Asphalt-Coated Roofing Sheets |
| CSA | A123.3 | Asphalt Saturated Organic Roofing Felt |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A123.4 | Asphalt for Constructing Built-Up Roof Coverings and Waterproofing Systems |
| CSA | A123.5 | Asphalt shingles made from glass felt and surfaced with mineral granules |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A123.16 | Asphalt-coated glass-base sheets |
| CSA | A123.17 | Asphalt Glass Felt Used in Roofing and Waterproofing |
| CSA | A123.23 | Product specification for polymer-modified bitumen sheet, prefabricated and reinforced |
| CSA | A123.51 | Asphalt shingle application on roof slopes 1:6 and steeper |
| CSA | A165.1 | Concrete block masonry units |
| CSA | A165.2 | Concrete brick masonry units |
| CSA | A165.3 | Prefaced concrete masonry units |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A179 | Mortar and Grout for Unit Masonry |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A220 Series | Concrete Roof Tiles |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-A371 | Masonry Construction for Buildings |
| CSA | A3001 | Cementitious Materials for Use in Concrete |
| CSA | B182.1 | Plastic drain and sewer pipe and pipe fittings |
| CSA | G40.21 | Structural quality steel |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-G401 | Corrugated steel pipe products |
| CSA | CAN/CSA-O80 Series | Wood preservation |
| CSA | O118.1 | Western Red Cedar Shakes and Shingles |
| CSA | O118.2 | Eastern White Cedar Shingles |
| CSA | O121 | Douglas fir plywood |
| CSA | O141 | Softwood Lumber |
| CSA | O151 | Canadian softwood plywood |
| CSA | O153 | Poplar plywood |
| CSA | O325 | Construction sheathing |
| CSA | O437.0 | OSB and Waferboard |
| HPVA | ANSI/HPVA HP-1 | American National Standard for Hardwood and Decorative Plywood |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S701.1 | Standard for Thermal Insulation, Polystyrene Boards |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S702.1 | Standard for Mineral Fibre Thermal Insulation for Buildings, Part 1: Material Specification |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S703 | Standard for Cellulose Fibre Insulation (CFI) for Buildings |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S704.1 | Standard for Thermal Insulation, Polyurethane and Polyisocyanurate, Boards, Faced |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S705.1 | Standard for Thermal Insulation – Spray Applied Rigid Polyurethane Foam, Medium Density – Material Specification |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S705.2 | Standard for Thermal Insulation – Spray Applied Rigid Polyurethane Foam, Medium Density – Application |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S706.1 | Standard for Wood Fibre Insulating Boards for Buildings |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S710.1 | Standard for Bead-Applied One Component Polyurethane Air Sealant Foam, Part 1: Material Specification |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S711.1 | Standard for Bead-Applied Two Component Polyurethane Air Sealant Foam, Part 1: Material Specification |
| ULC | CAN/ULC-S717.1 | Standard for Flat Wall Insulating Concrete Form (ICF) Units – Material Properties |
Impact analysis
This proposed change is expected to have a positive impact in that it would resolve all potential conflicts created by referencing two duplicate standards for compliance.
Enforcement implications
Removing the reference to ASTM D2178/D2178M-13a from the NBC would also remove the potential confusion and conflict that could be created if an authority having jurisdiction were to demand proof of compliance to both standards.
Who is affected
Designers, specification writers, manufacturers, building owners, building officials, lawyers and contractors. These groups would benefit from the elimination of the potential confusion and conflict addressed above.
OBJECTIVE-BASED ANALYSIS OF NEW OR CHANGED PROVISIONS
NBC20 Div.B 5.9.1.1. (first printing)
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F20,F22,F51,F54,F55,F61,F63,F80-OH1.1,OH1.2][F41,F55-OH1.1][F55,F61,F80-OH1.3]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F20,F80-OS2.1][F20,F22,F51,F61,F63,F80-OS2.3][F51-OS2.5]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F20-OS2.2][F80-OS2.3]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F80,F61,F63-OS3.1]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F80,F61,F63-OH4]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) ([a] a) [F61,F63-OS1.4]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F20,F80-OP2.1,OP2.3][F22,F80-OP2.4]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([1] 1) [F42-OH2.5]
[5.9.1.1.] 5.9.1.1. ([2] 2) no attributions
- Date modified: